Polkassembly Logo

Create Pencil IconCreate
Chat with KlaraComing Soon
OpenGov
View All Discussion

[Account identity] Modify DOT deposit amount to incentivize people to set & verify on-chain identity

userCryptoSurfer
2 years ago
identity

Recently i set up my identity on Polkadot with verification process.

https://support.polkadot.network/support/solutions/articles/65000181981-how-to-set-and-clear-an-identity

That's something i usually do whenever i can on the parachains i use more & vote on, and i made it a long time ago on Kusama.

But why was i reluctant to do it on Polkadot ? **Because there is this 20.258 DOT deposit

**

For comparison:

Kusama deposit = 0.333333333 KSM = 7.52$ (current price)

Polkadot deposit = 20.258 DOT = 101.49$ (current price)

So the current ratio between the 2 deposit amounts is 13.5.

For an average user, setting an identity on Kusama is no big deal at this price, but on Polkadot it's already something with the 100$ mental threshold. And don't imagine anyone during a bull market depositing 500$ just to set-up an identity.

Future scenario:

Kusama deposit = 0.333333333 KSM = 7.52$ x10 = 75$ -> remains acceptable

Polkadot deposit = 20.258 DOT = 101.49$ x10 = 1014$ -> **just not sustainable

**Today's ratio between KSM & DOT prices is 4.5, and historically was higher. So if we want to maintain this kind of ratio between Kusama and Polkadot deposit, current DOT deposit should not be over 6.75 DOT.

**=> So it's a 4.5 price ratio vs 13.5 deposit ratio.

**Even with this new DOT deposit, it won't be sustainable in a future scenario where prices x10.

I'd like to see the current DOT deposit to be changed and set to the current KSM/DOT ratio = 4.5
I would propose:

Kusama deposit = 0.333333333 KSM => No change

Polkadot deposit = 6.75 DOT => To be changed

And in my best dreams i'd like the deposit not to be static and capped to a reasonable $ amount (let's 100$ for intance) so that majority of people can set on-chain identities even during a bull market.

I'd like to have the temperature of the community and understand what was the idea behind this high threshold on Polkadot.

In the poll:
AYE if you want to lower the current DOT deposit
NAYE if you are good with the current situation

Comments (5)

2 years ago

Gabe & I were talking about this the other week. I agree that it's rather high at the moment, an amount that will rise in USD as the price of DOT rises. If comparing to past highs in the $50 range, this is an unreasonable amount IMO.

The current amount can actually be rather discouraging for many, so I believe it's good to explore lowering it to something closer to 5 DOT.

2 years ago

Sik would vote for 5 DOT max! 
Identities shouldn't be a thing for the rich && the famous 🤓

2 years ago

@dev0_sik Definitely YES
I think the 20 DOT deposit was decided at DOT launch, so with a very low price.

Load more comments
PleaseLogin to comment

Help Center

Report an Issue
Feedback
Terms and Conditions
Github

Our Services

Docs
Terms of Website
Privacy Policy

A House of Commons Initiative.

Polka Labs Private Limited 2025

All rights reserved.

Terms and ConditionsTerms of Website
Privacy Policy